Lessons from Lent: On Sex, Alcohol and the CDC
Recently my pastor shared a passage from Barbara Cawthorne Crafton in the book, Bread and Wine: Readings for Lent and Easter. Crafton starts her essay saying:
We didn’t even know what moderation was. What it felt like. We didn’t just work: we inhaled our jobs, sucked them in, became them. Stayed late, brought work home – it was never enough, though, no matter how much time we put in.
She goes on, weaving a picture of lack of moderation, and then says:
We felt that it was important to be good to ourselves, and that this meant that it was dangerous to tell ourselves no. About anything, ever. Repression of one’s desires was an unhealthy thing. I work hard, we told ourselves. I deserve a little treat. We treated ourselves every day.
During Lent, Christians claim boldly that it is not dangerous to tell ourselves no, but it is the utmost of spiritual practices. We willingly give up our “needs” to focus on something beyond ourselves.
That’s why the response to the CDC’s recommendation for women of child bearing years to not drink alcohol if they might become pregnant (so, any woman sexually active), is so alarming.
I saw many of my Christian friends condemning this recommendation because it infringed on their rights.
These Christians agreed with the reaction from the media, most having responses similar to what the L.A. Times said, “…[a woman is] a potential fetal incubator — a fact you should be aware of, and planning around, at all times.”
I shouldn’t be surprised as more and more often nowadays Christians get offended by the thought of giving up alcohol. We desire it so we deserve it as something our freedom in Christ grants us. Jesus drank wine, right?
And we’re in a cultural Christian climate where, while still promoting sexual abstinence for the unmarried, pastors claim having more marital sex is the thing to do.
So, just like from the quote above, Christians think “it [is] dangerous to tell ourselves no.” But if we don’t tell ourselves no, we miss out on what the Lenten season tries to bring about—that telling ourselves “no” actually brings about peace, clarity and focus.
Photo by kimerydavis 
Related Posts
About The Author
Bethany Sundstrom-Smith
Bethany Sundstrom-Smith holds a Master's Degree in Theology (Th.M.) with a focus in Media Arts from Dallas Theological Seminary. Her background is in journalism, marketing, and making lattes. She lives in Portland and runs Cadia Marketing and Food Blog Usability.
I really like this. Thanks for this post. We all need to be told “no” sometimes and we all need to tell ourselves “no” sometimes. Again, thanks!!
“But if we don’t tell ourselves no, we miss out in what the Lenten season tries to bring about. That telling ourselves “no” actually brings about peace, clarity and focus and in no way infringes on our rights.”
Indeed!
I was a bit confused when I first followed the links because I expected “the CDC’s recommendation [to be] for women of child bearing years to not drink alcohol if they might become pregnant (so, any woman sexually active).” When what it actually says is use birth control or avoid alcohol. If the government really were suggesting all [heterosexual] premenopausal sexually active women abstain from alcohol at all times, I’d take serious issue with such a recommendation too.
While somewhat reactionary in its tone — especially the title and introduction — the Times article doesn’t read as alarmist to me. On the contrary, it offers an important balance to the CDC’s conservative recommendation (the tone of which is a bit alarmist itself). Furthermore, there are valid reasons that the CDC’s language and iconographics have raised hackles — including placing the onus of birth control solely on women’s shoulders — and to suggest those reasons boil down to mere self-centeredness and indulgence is to oversimplify the issue. In the same way, while sin nature is certainly a reason Christians push back against telling ourselves “no,” another is a legitimate wariness of legalistic asceticism preached in many avenues of American Christianity.
Certainly, we need to tell ourselves “no.” And we need to discipline ourselves to submit to the “no” of others (when appropriate). The spiritual fight against our cultural (and human) sense of entitlement is essential to our humanity, and as such, a central pillar of Christian ethics. However. The significance of the Church Calendar is the Ecclesiastical truth that there is a season for everything: fasting and feasting, saying no and saying yes.